2025 Nominations Query Post

[tavina]

Hello Hello!

We have some nominations queries! Please let us know within 24 hours about how we might update these tags, so we can get the bulk of tagset cleanup under way!

Relationships and Characters:

• Alan Wake (Video Games)
• Fictional Alex Casey/Fictional Ilmo Koskela (Alan Wake)
• Nominator, we’re not sure that “Fictional Ilmo Koskela” is a canonical character in this game. Can you, or anyone else that’s familiar with this game let us know? Thank you!
• Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
• 1: Founder Undercover at Starfleet Headquarters as Admiral Leyton Who Transforms into a Bird (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)
• Nominator, would you mind if we accepted this as “1: Founder-imposter Admiral Leyton (DS9)” for the sake of making this nomination more succinct?
• Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types
• Nominator, I’ve heard from you a bit about why you’d prefer All Media Types for this fandom - other people who might request or offer this fandom, would you take this to be “I don’t really care which version of canon I get” ? I’m not inherently opposed to accepting this as it’s own thing outside of the games, show, and books for this year, though I think in future we might want to discuss this a bit more on a future Franchises Post to clarify what we mean, since we use Star Wars - AMT to catch Star Wars inter-canon crossovers. (Though I suppose that might be more of an edge case than anything.)
• 燕云十六声 | Where Winds Meet (Video Game)
• Tags with “Female Shao Dong Jia” - Nominator(s) can you confirm that Shao Dong Jia is the player character or that their gender is customizable in game (and therefore that there’s a corresponding Male Shao Dong Jia)? If there’s only one canonical gender for this character, would it be acceptable to accept these nominations as Shao Dong Jia? Sorry, I wasn’t able to find a character list for this game when investigating!

Freeforms:

• ALL: Alternative Hanahaki AU
• Nominator, we’d prefer a bit more specificity on what kind of alternate hanahaki au you’re looking for, can you update us on what kind of Alternative Hanahaki? (Platonic Hanahaki? Hanahaki where they cough up lizards? Hanahaki that doesn’t kill you? Hanahaki that doesn’t require a confession? Something else entirely?)
• ALL: Bad Guys Win
• Nominator, we have “ALL: The bad guys win/The good guys fail” in the tagset already - is this an acceptable tag, or were you aiming for something slightly different with this nomination? Let us know your thoughts!
• ALL: Different characters get together
• Nominator, we discussed and thought this tag might be a bit confusing esp if you end up requesting canonical ships. This might be something that’s already baked into the ships you request, even if it’s technically an AU. If you were thinking of a more specific scenario/think there’s a way to clarify this that we haven’t thought of, please let us know!
• ALL: Hogwarts AU
• Nominator, we already have “ALL: Harry Potter AU - Hogwarts Setting” in the tagset! Were you thinking of a different kind of Hogwarts AU? Let us know if what’s already in the tagset makes sense for what you’d like to request!
• ALL: Superheroes AU
• Nominator, we already have “ALL: Superhero/Supervillain AU” in the tagset! Let us know if this tag would be what you’re interested in requesting and/or offering, or if there’s a way to clarify that this tag is substantially different!
• White Collar: AU where Neal is not a CI but an indentured slave and Peter and El take him in (with or without smexy tiems).
• Nominator, I appreciate your love for this specific scenario, but we discussed and felt that this might be a bit too much of a “boxing your creator into writing one very specific prompt” situation. Would it be acceptable to you to accept this tag as “White Collar: Neal is an indentured slave AU” ?

Rejected Tags with Undefined/Too Large Groups:

• All for the Game:
• Palmetto State Foxes Members & Neil Josten (AFTG)
• Avatar the Last Airbender:
• The Gaang & Zuko (Avatar)
• Critical Role Exandria:
• Bells Hells & Ashton Greymoore (CritRole Exandria)
• Bells Hells & Orym (CritRole Exandria)
• Cerberus Assembly & Caleb Widogast (CritRole Exandria)
• The Mighty Nein & Caleb Widogast (CritRole Exandria)
• Volstrucker & Caleb Widogast (CritRole Exandria)
• DCU Comics
• Batfamily Members & Dick Grayson (DCU)
• Fire Emblem Three Houses
• Byleth Eisner and Blue Lions Students (FE:3H)
• Marvel 616
• Beyond Corporation & Ben Reilly (616)
• God Fighters Team & Ben Reilly (616)
• Percy Jackson and the Olympians
• Camp Half-Blood Campers & Luke Castellan (PJO)
• Kronos Army Demigods & Luke Castellan (PJO)
• The Gods & Luke Castellan (PJO)
• Teen Wolf TV
• The Pack & Stiles Stilinski (Teen Wolf)
• Young Justice Cartoon
• Dick Grayson & Members of the Team (YJ Cartoon)
• Pluribus
• The Others & Carol Sturka (Pluribus)
• The Others/Carol Sturka (Pluribus)

If any of the nominators of these rejected tags would like to discuss re: this group being well defined and not more than 6 distinct people (unfortunately, guaranteeing a work will include all the members of a group that’s larger than 6 + anyone else in the nomination already is very difficult even for a 5k event!) please let us know in the next 24-48 hours, and we can add the nomination back in!

2025 Tagset Cleanup Post

[tavina]

See any duplicates in the tagset(s)? A misspelling? Comment down below to let us know as we start to work through tagset cleanup!!