Tagset Cleanup Post!

[tavina]

See any duplicates in the tagset(s)? A misspelling? Comment down below to let us know as we start to work through tagset cleanup!!

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Potentially, ALL: Characters Have Wings & ALL: Wingfic AU?

I suppose they might be separate enough on their own, if the first reads as all characters have wings, compared to latter where only some characters have wings?

[unhindered_dreams]

Relationship Tagset:

Under: Warlock (1989)

Chas (Warl) should be 1: Chas (Warlock)
Giles Redferne (Warl) should be 1: Giles Redferne (Warlock)
Kassandra (Warl) should be 1: Kassandra (Warlock)
Unbaptized Boy (Warl) should be 1: Unbaptized Boy (Warlock)
Warlock (Warl) should be 1: Warlock (Warlock)



Freeform Tagset:

I noticed two tags with an extra ALL:

All: ALL: Fantasy/Magic Organized Crime AU
and
All: ALL: Fantasy/Magic Royalty and Palace Intrigue AU

[sarriathmg]

"Dick Grayson/Jason Todd (DCU Comics)" appears in both "DCU (Comics)" and "Young Justice (Cartoon)". It might have been nominated only in DCU comics but wandered over to YJ cartoon by itself. Is it possible to delete the YJ version and still keep the DCU version? Or change the one under YJ to "Dick Grayson/Jason Todd (Young Justice Cartoon)". (I'm concerned about the duplication causing problems in signup and matching, as well as deleting one can cause the other to delete as well, but I'm not that familiar with tagset management)

[taken_aback_by_tuesdays]

Under Harry Potter - JK Rowling is the tag: John Kowalski & Francesca Lam (Revolutionary Arc)

[taken_aback_by_tuesdays]

I'm not sure how ALL: Harry Potter AU and ALL: Hogwarts AU are different.

[dontstophernow]

These are fixed. Thanks!

[taken_aback_by_tuesdays]

There's both ALL: College AU and ALL: University/College AU

[(Anonymous)]

Some duplicates:

ALL: Modern with Magic
ALL: Modern with Magic AU

ALL: Horror
All: Horror AU

ALL: Ghost Hunters
ALL: Ghost Hunter AU

ALL: Character A is a figure skater and Character B is a hockey player
ALL: Figure Skater/Hockey Player AU

[dontstophernow]

I did change the DCU Comics version to "Dick Grayson/Jason Todd (DCU Comics DFE)" and Young Justice Cartoon to "Dick Grayson/Jason Todd (YJ Cartoon)" so they're not using the same disambiguation and wander.

[dontstophernow]

This is fixed!

[(Anonymous)]

* All: Actor AU & All: Actors AU
* ALL: A and B are secretly married the whole time & ALL: Secretly married all along AU & (arguably) ALL: Pretending Not to Be Dating / Married AU
* ALL: SCP Foundation AU & ALL: SCP Foundation Fusion
* ALL: All But One Character is Played by the Muppets & ALL: All characters except one are Muppets
* ALL: Alternate First Meeting & ALL: Different First Meeting AU
* ALL: Firefly (2002 TV) Fusion & ALL: Firefly AU
* All: Figure skating AU & ALL: Ice Skating AU
* ALL: Loveless AU (anime/manga) & ALL: Loveless fusion - on this one worth noting that iirc there’s a YA novel named Loveless that’s semi popular
* ALL: Magical Girl AU & All: Magical Girls/Boys AU
* Grogu & Luke Skywalker (Mandalorian) & Grogu & Luke Skywalker (The Mandalorian (TV))
* Alexis | Quackity/Wilbur Soot (Video Blogging RPF) & Quackity/Wilbur Soot (Dream SMP) - unsure if this is a wandering tag situation, the disambig makes me think maybe but they both appear under Video Blogging RPF
And this is hardly the end of the world but in Penumbra Podcast the tag “1: Juno Steele (Penumbra)” has a typo, the character’s surname is Steel.

[withthekeyisking]

All For The Game - Nora Sakavic

Aaron Minyard & Andrew Minyard (AFTG)
Aaron Minyard & Andrew Minyard (All For The Game - Nora Sakavic)

Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard (AFTG)
Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard (All For The Game - Nora Sakavic)


Arcane: League of Legends (Cartoon 2021)

Ekko & Jinx (A:LoL)
Ekko & Jinx (Arcane)

Ekko/Jinx (A:LoL)
Ekko/Jinx (Arcane)

Jayce/Viktor (A:LoL)
Jayce/Viktor (Arcane)

Jinx & Vi (A:LoL)
Jinx & Vi (Arcane)

I also saw some of the relationships queried on the new post are relationships already in the A:LOL fandom in the tagset, so don't have to be approved at all.


DCU (Comics)

Clark Kent/Bruce Wayne (DCU (Comics))
Clark Kent/Bruce Wayne (DCU Comics)

Clark Kent/Lois Lane (DCU (Comics))
Clark Kent/Lois Lane (DCU Comics)

Jason Todd & Bruce Wayne (DCU (Comics))
Jason Todd & Bruce Wayne (DCU Comics)

Jason Todd/Slade Wilson (DCU Comics)
Jason Todd/Slade Wilson (DCU)

Roy Harper/Jason Todd (DCU (Comics))
Roy Harper/Jason Todd (DCU Comics)


Separate fandoms same meaning:
The Defenders (Marvel TV)
The Defenders (TV)


AU: One or more characters has amnesia
is this supposed to be under ALL?

[dontstophernow]

I removed the duplicates on Grogu & Luke Skywalker (Mandalorian).

All of the MCYT tags are wandering. For those, as long as it's definitely in the right place, it's okay for it also to be wandering.

I've updated 1: Juno Steel (Penumbra) to the correct spelling.

We'll do a mass-update to the Freeforms separately, but thank you for letting us know about these!

[dontstophernow]

The AU Freeform, AFTG, Arcane, DCU Comics, and The Defenders are all fixed now.

[(Anonymous)]

A duplicate in Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series):
Giovanni/Silver (Pokemon MVGS)
Sakaki | Giovanni/Silver (Pokemon MVGS)

[(Anonymous)]

Dante & Vergil (DmC) > Dante & Vergil (DMC)

DMC and DmC are two different games, and DmC is, uh, notoriously disliked.

[primeideal]

Some of these have been listed above but here are several freeforms you might want to look into:

ALL: A Character is a Dragon AU
ALL: Dragons - Canon character(s) is/are dragons (with or without humanoid forms)

ALL: All But One Character is Played by the Muppets
ALL: All characters except one are Muppets

ALL: Canonical universe works on musical theater tropes
ALL: Musical - Canon is now a musical and everyone sings their feelings
ALL: Once More With Feeling (Buffy Episode) AU

ALL: Character A is a figure skater and Character B is a hockey player
ALL: Figure Skater/Hockey Player AU

All: Figure skating AU
ALL: Ice Skating AU

ALL: Ghost Hunter AU
ALL: Ghost Hunters

ALL: Horror
All: Horror AU

ALL: Loveless AU (anime/manga)
ALL: Loveless fusion

ALL: Modern with Magic
ALL: Modern with Magic AU

ALL: Character Who Betrays Another Character in Canon Doesn't AU
ALL: No Betrayal AU

ALL: All Human AU
ALL: Non-Human Characters are Human

ALL: Role Reversal AU
ALL: Roleswap AU

ALL: A and B are secretly married the whole time
ALL: Secretly married all along AU

ALL: Character Is a Spy
ALL: Spies AU

ALL: College AU
ALL: University/College AU

ALL: Werewolves
ALL: Werewolves AU

[tavina]

This has been fixed! Thank you!

[tavina]

Unfortunately, Dante & Vergil (DMC) always corrects to the DmC version on AO3 so I've re-added this relationship as Dante & Vergil (DMC - DFE) to combat it!

[tavina]

I think these two are sufficiently different to keep both in the tagset! Thanks for bringing it to our attention!

[withthekeyisking]

Tags with the same meaning!

ALL: Character has an amnesia
ALL: One or more characters has amnesia

[primeideal]

Some more freeforms:

ALL: Character has an amnesia
ALL: One or more characters has amnesia

Star Wars: Anakin is honest with Yoda about his visions and gets help
Star Wars: Anakin tells Yoda the truth about his visions and gets help

[primeideal]

There's "Les Miserables--All Media Types" and "Les Miserables--Victor Hugo" with duplicate tags, I'm not sure if that's just wandering or they were nominated separately.

[tavina]

Thank you! These have been hunted down!

[tavina]

Thank you! This ALL: College AU has been removed in favor of keeping ALL: University/College AU!

[tavina]

Thank you! The nominator of ALL: Hogwarts AU got back to us and explained that they'd like ALL: Hogwarts AU to focus on the setting of Hogwarts instead of a more general Harry Potter AU, and ALL: Hogwarts AU has been updated to ALL: Harry Potter AU - Hogwarts Setting to reflect this more accurately!

[tavina]

I think we'll keep both of these fandoms this year since it's not clear at this point if the tags have wandered or if these were nominated separately. Thank you so much for letting us know about this!

[tavina]

Some of these have been updated so that only one remains, others we left because we felt cases could be made for them being nuanced and distinct. Thank you so much for helping us hunt down so many dupes!

[tavina]

Thanks for letting us know about these! Ultimately we felt like these had nuance/could be seen as distinct from one another, so they both remain in the tagset!

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! I know signups are already open but as I was doing my signup, I noticed some duplicate/incorrectly sorted relationship tags in 魔道祖师 - 墨香铜臭 | Módào Zǔshī - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù, which I’ll list below:

“Lan Wangji/Wei Wuxian (MDZS)“ and “Lán Zhàn | Lán Wàngjī/Wèi Yīng | Wèi Wúxiàn (MDZS - MXTX)”

“Nie Huaisang & Nie Mingjue (MDZS)” and “ Nie Huaisang & Nie Mingjue (The Untamed)”